Introduction to Credit Scorecard

A credit scorecard is a statistical model used by lenders to evaluate the risk of lending money to consumers. It helps in determining the creditworthiness of an individual by scoring various aspects of their financial history and current financial status. The scorecard is designed to predict the likelihood that a borrower will repay a loan on time. Start Free Trial

Introduction to Credit Scorecard

Who should use a Credit Scorecard?

Credit scorecards are essential tools for lenders to evaluate the financial health and creditworthiness of applicants and the following type of lenders use credit scorecards:

Lender Types Purpose of Using Credit Scorecard
Banks and Financial Institutions To assess the creditworthiness of individuals for personal loans, mortgages, or credit lines.
Credit Card Issuers For evaluating applications for new credit cards and determining credit limits and interest rates.
Auto Loan Providers To decide on the approval and terms of car loans, including interest rates and down payment
requirements.
Mortgage Lenders To evaluate the risk of lending for home purchases and set loan terms like interest rates and amounts.
Retailers Offering Financing For assessing the risk of offering instalment payments or personal lines of credit to customers.
Peer-to-Peer Lending Platforms To assess borrower risk profiles and set interest rates on loans funded by individual investors.

Credit Scorecard has become more important than ever for a Lender.

  1. Growing Complexity of Financial Markets: As financial markets have become more complex and diverse, with new types of credit products and services being introduced, credit scorecards provide a systematic way to evaluate and manage risk across different products and customer segments.
  2. Increased Volume of Credit Applications: With the rise of digital banking and online applications, the volume of credit applications has surged. Credit scorecards enable efficient, scalable, and consistent decision-making processes to handle this increased volume without compromising on the quality of credit assessments.
  3. Advancements in Data Analytics and Technology: The evolution of data analytics, artificial intelligence, and machine learning technologies has significantly improved the accuracy and predictive power of credit scorecards. These advancements allow for more nuanced and sophisticated models that can better predict borrower behaviour and outcomes.
  4. Regulatory Compliance and Fair Lending: Tighter regulatory scrutiny around credit practices and the need for transparency and fairness in lending decisions have underscored the importance of using objective and quantifiable measures like credit scorecards. They help ensure that lending decisions are made consistently and are compliant with laws such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA).
  5. Consumer Demand for Faster Credit Decisions: Consumers increasingly expect quick responses to their credit applications, driven by the immediacy of digital transactions. Credit scorecards facilitate rapid decision-making, allowing lenders to meet consumer expectations for speed without sacrificing accuracy or increasing risk.
  6. Risk Management and Credit Quality: Following financial crises and economic downturns, there’s heightened awareness of the importance of sound risk management practices. Credit scorecards play a crucial role in identifying, assessing, and managing credit risk, helping to maintain the credit quality of lenders’ portfolios.
  7. Access to Big Data: The availability of big data and the ability to process it have allowed for the development of more detailed and accurate credit scorecards. Lenders can now incorporate a wider range of data points, including non-traditional data, to make better-informed lending decisions.
  8. Financial Inclusion: Credit scorecards, especially those incorporating alternative data, can help in extending credit to underserved or thin-file consumers who might not have a traditional credit history. This contributes to financial inclusion by allowing more individuals to access credit.

Guide to building a Credit Scorecard

The following steps are performed at Roopya Scorecard Building process. These may vary based on product type, available parameters etc. Some sample queries are shared here.

1. Extract input data from the source

guide-to-building-credit-scorecard1

guide-to-building-credit-scorecard2

2. Select the product type to create scorecard

guide-to-building-credit-scorecard3

3. Define ‘Good’ / ‘Bad’ basis delinquency

4. Outlier detection and treatment

  1. Detected outliers using the Z-score method to enhance data quality and analysis.
  2. Standard Scaler from scikit-learn applied to normalize numerical columns.
  3. Z-scores calculated as absolute values of (data – mean) / standard deviation.
  4. Threshold set at 3 to identify extreme outliers.
  5. Created a matrix displaying ‘Outlier’ labels for each column and row.
  6. Counted and reported the number of outliers per column for insights.
  7. Outliers highlighted for potential further investigation and action.

guide-to-building-credit-scorecard4

  1. Define Outlier Bounds

guide-to-building-credit-scorecard5

correlation-heatmap-features

5. Correlation heatmap of features

weight-of-evidence-calculation

6. Weight of evidence calculation

The Information Value (IV) is calculated for each column and is a measure of its ability to separate good and bad accounts. The IV for a column is the sum of IV values for all categories within that column. The formula to calculate the IV for a column is as follows

weight-of-evidence-calculation2

7. Predictiveness: Based on the calculated IV values, the code assigns a level of predictiveness to each column:

  1. Not useful for prediction (IV < 0.02)
  2. Weak predictive power(0.02
  3. Medium predictive power(0.1
  4. Strong predictive power (0.3
  5. Suspicious predictive power(IV >= 0.5)

predictiveness

8. Evaluation metrics
Several evaluation metrics are calculated to assess the model’s performance, including:

  1. Accuracy
  2. F1 Score
  3. Precision
  4. Recall
  5. ROC-AUC Score
  6. The Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curve is generated to visualize models good bad classification power.
  7. A classification report provides detailed metrics for both classes (Class 0 and Class 1).
  8. True Negatives (TN), False Positives (FP), False Negatives (FN), and True Positives (TP) are determined using a confusion matrix

predictive-power-model

Following determine predictive power of model:

Following determine ROC curve and ROC-AUC Score of a model

9. Generate final scorecard: We can use the scaling formula to convert predicted probabilities from logistic regression into credit scores. We can adjust the scaling parameters to fit your specific needs, such as minimum and maximum scores on a scale of 100.

Things to be taken care of while building a Credit Scorecard

These are the critical things to be taken care of while building a credit scorecard:
These are the critical things to be taken care of while building a credit scorecard:

Consideration Description
Data Quality Ensure the data used for building the scorecard is accurate, complete, and relevant. Inaccurate or
incomplete data can lead to misleading scores.
Regulatory Compliance The scorecard must comply with all relevant financial regulations and laws, such as the Fair Credit
Reporting Act (FCRA) and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA), to ensure fairness and
non-discrimination in lending.
Model Validation Regularly validate the model to ensure its predictions are still accurate and relevant. Validation
involves statistical testing and comparison against actual outcomes to assess performance.
Predictive Power The scorecard should have a strong predictive power, indicating a high ability to differentiate between
good and bad borrowers. This is often measured using statistics like the Gini coefficient or the area
under the ROC curve (AUC).
Feature Selection Carefully select features (variables) that are predictive of credit risk. Avoid variables that are not
predictive or could introduce bias. Consider both traditional data (e.g., credit history) and
alternative data (e.g., utility payments).
Bias and Fairness Assess and minimize any biases in the scorecard that could lead to unfair treatment of certain groups of
applicants. This includes ensuring the model does not unfairly penalize certain demographics.
Interpretability The model should be interpretable, meaning its decisions can be understood and explained. This is
important for regulatory compliance, model validation, and providing feedback to applicants who are
denied credit.
Scalability and Efficiency The scorecard should be able to handle the volume of applications expected, processing them efficiently
without sacrificing accuracy.
Adaptability and Updating Be prepared to update the scorecard over time as economic conditions, consumer behavior, and credit
markets evolve. This might involve adding new variables, adjusting weights, or retraining the model with
new data.
Transparency and Documentation Maintain thorough documentation of the model development process, including data sources, variable
selection rationale, model specifications, and validation results. This is crucial for regulatory
compliance and for maintaining trust in the model.